Punch needle embroidery is simple enough to learn in an afternoon, but takes many hours of practice to truly master.  If you are just starting out, read this guide all about Punch Needle Embroidery for Beginners.  It’s a complete guide with a rundown of all the punch needle supplies you’ll need to get started. 

After you experiment with the punch needle for a while, you may have some questions about the technique. If you need help troubleshooting problems with punch needle embroidery, read on for answers to frequently asked questions.

Beginning students come across a couple of common problems with their punch needle technique.  In the following article, I’ve tried to answer the most questions I receive most often.  You can also check out my Top 10 Tips for Punch Needle Embroidery for even more info.

Why won’t my loops stay in place?

Got punch needle problems? When I first started punch needle, I had trouble keeping my stitches from unraveling — so I understand the frustration. There are a couple reasons why your loops won’t stay in the fabric.

Most likely, your loops are coming out because you are pulling your needle tip too far away from the surface of your fabric in between stitches. If you pull your needle too far out of the fabric, the stitch comes out with it. To fix this, try to keep the tip of the needle in contact with the surface of the fabric as you pull out and move along your row of stitches. Remember that there is nothing actually holding your loops in place except the tension in the weave of the fabric and the friction of all the stitches packed together. So, if you pull out too far, the loop comes right out with the needle tool. 

The second reason why your stitches aren’t staying in could be that there is tension on your yarn.  You want to keep your yarn held loosely — it needs to be able to flow freely through your punch needle. If it is caught up on something, or you are accidentally resting your frame or elbow on the yarn, the tension will pull the loops out.

If that doesn’t fix the problem, double check that you are holding your punch needle tool so that it’s facing the direction of your stitches. Make sure that you are holding the punch needle like a pen and positioning it perpendicular to the fabric. The open/slanted edge of the needle faces in the direction you are moving across the fabric. Make sure the tail of your thread is trailing behind where you are punching.

Why are my loops uneven on the front-side of my piece?

If your stitches look uneven on the front side of your fabric, you may not be punching the needle all the way into the fabric.  To fix this, make sure to punch the needle down all the way down to the plastic/wooden handle on every stitch. This will ensure that your yarn loops are a uniform length.

Or, it could be that you are lifting the needle too high off the fabric in between stitches. So instead, make sure that after you have punched down through the fabric, you lift your needle slowly just to the surface of the fabric. Then, slide your needle over the surface of the fabric and punch your next stitch.

And thirdly, it could be that your fabric is too loose. Loose monk’s cloth can cause uneven loops. To fix this, tighten the fabric in the frame. Your monk’s cloth should be as tight as a drum!

Help! The backing fabric is showing through on the front side of my work.

If your backing fabric is showing through on the front side of your work, it means that you are punching too far apart for the size of the yarn that you are using.  Either your stitches or your rows of stitches are punched too far apart from each other. The appropriate space between rows and stitches depends on the thickness of the yarn you have chosen.  For most, 4-6 stitches per inch is appropriate.

If you need to fix empty holes, you can go back over a punched section and add more stitches.  This will add loops on the front by adding additional stitches on the back side.

I can’t find Monk’s Cloth.  Can I use Aida cloth for punch needle?

Monk’s cloth is my favorite foundation fabric — just make sure that you are using the tighter weave monk’s cloth with approximately 12 holes per inch.  If you can’t find monk’s cloth, you may be able to find primitive linen or primary rug backing.

Aida cloth is most commonly used for cross-stitch embroidery.   It is available in different “counts”, which represent the number of cross stitches per inch the fabric will hold.  Theoretically, you could use it as a foundation for punch needle, but I wouldn’t recommend it if you can find Monk’s Cloth instead.  If you want to experiment with it, choose the higher count cloth, such as 18-count Aida, which may provide better results

I can’t find rug yarn.  What else can I use?

3-ply wool Rug yarn is most commonly use for punch needle.  But if you can’t find it, you can experiment with knitting yarn you can find at most craft and hobby stores.

Rug yarn is a similar weight to bulky-weight knitting yarn.  For the regular size Amy Oxford needle, for instance, you’ll want a yarn that is about 1/8” thick.  Look for yarn that is made of wool if you want a very durable finished project.  If your finished project will not see a lot of wear — if you are making a wall hanging, for example — feel free to use yarn with other fiber content.  You can use cotton yarn, acrylic, or other blends.  You can also double, triple, and quadruple finer yarns and use them together in the punch.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

48 Comments

  1. Can you please show how to stretch monk cloth on griper frame? Mine just keps coming off.

  2. My finished punch needle trivet curls up at edges and is not staying flat . How can I fix it please?

    1. Sarah Stearns says:

      Hi, If you’ve made it out of wool yarn, you can try wet blocking it or steam blocking it.

  3. Hi, I’m having trouble punching perfectly round circles, especially small ones. I’m on #1 slot on my ultra punch and using 6 strands of DMC floss. I’ve tried punching around the perimeter of the circle and punching across the circle and then under and over it with decreasing stitches, neither of which is getting me the result I want. Any help?

    1. Hi Nancy,
      You might try using shorter stitches or working with less than 6 strands.

  4. Alexsandra says:

    Hi Sarah.
    Im a beginner and I’m using an embroidery pen with 6 string embroidery thread. I was told I could use a certain cotton fabric but it keeps tearing every time I punch next to a hole I punched already. What can I do?

    1. Hi, the fabric you’ll want to use is called Weaver’s cloth. It doesn’t tear like some other fabrics can.

  5. Shelly Block says:

    hello, will unprimed painters cotton canvas work the same as the month’s cloth or rug warp when punch needling a rug? it’s a LOT cheaper and seems just as sturdy but still seems to move. thanks, Shelly

    1. Hi Shelly,
      I have not tried it, so I can’t say for sure. I’m thinking the weave may be too tight.

  6. Pingback: How to Make A Punch Needle Pillow - Sarah Maker
  7. Jane teske says:

    Can not pass my threader through the needle to grab the thread. Do I need to take this apart and is so how.

    1. Hi Jane, What needle tool do you have?

  8. Alice Qiu says:

    Hi Sarah!

    Is there any way to make sure my piece doesn’t curl after I take it off the frame? I’m trying to make a rug, so I would like it to be flat as possible.

    Thank you!

  9. Hope Amen says:

    Hello. I am working on my first piece. Using a snap frame, Oxford punch needle and worsted yarn. I completed the main part of the piece and took it off the snap frame to re adjust it and it is curling up. What did I do wrong?

    1. Yes, it can curl. Are you planning on making a pillow?

  10. Judith Rohlfer says:

    CAN YOU MACHINE WASH PUNCH EMBROIDERY? I’M WANTING TO DO A OUTLINE STITCH FOR A SUN BONNET SUE BABY QUILT.
    THANKS…

    1. Hi Judith,
      I haven’t tried it, but my feeling is no.

  11. Hi Sarah – I’m so inspired by your work! I dabble in lots of fiber arts (macrame, crochet, cross stitch) and am now trying my hand at punch needle. I have a kit bought from a great seller in my country (Australia) that includes monks cloth stapled to a frame, yarn and and #10 Oxford needle. I’ve been watching tutorials for weeks so felt ready today. All in all I was happy with my first attempts (I made all the beginner errors but I recognized them straight away and was able to rectify them). My only question is one I haven’t seen talked about anywhere and that is a few times I “punched through” a loop from a previous row, causing some of the yarn in that loop to split/stretch up (so it had and additional higher loop – if that makes sense?). I was able to trim those bits off easily enough but still…Do you hold your previous row out the way? Seems like a good idea, but I’m afraid I’ll stab myself! Is this a common problem, something you’ve encountered, or just a “me thing”?!

    1. Hi Anglea,
      That’s a really good question. That scenario has happened to me only a couple of times — but I know what you’re talking about. If I have one loop that looks snagged, I usually just trim it. Maybe you could experiment with angling your punch needle tool away from the previous rows. (I know for me, holding the tool in my right hand, my needle tip has a tendency to point toward the left.)

  12. Nova Warne says:

    Hi Sarah, a great big hello from Australia! I have doing punch needle for some time however due to some health problems have found it hard to get back into. BUT having said that I’m looking at a project which has a face on it and am wondering what you would recommend as far as stitch lengths to obtain a contour to the face; I’m thinking for example along the cheek line a slightly longer stitch than the rest of the face? And I’m curious as to what colour DMC cotton you would use for a project like this? Thanks for your help Sarah.

    1. Sure, what type of punch needle are you using?

  13. catherine says:

    Hi Sarah,
    I’m usually a pretty easy going person, but rug punching is changing me into a monster. I’m trying, I really am, tonight though I tossed balls of yarn though the room as I became more and more upset. The yarn won’t stay in the puncher and when in goes through the monk’s cloth it brings extra yarn with it. I’m constantly pulling the material to keep it taught, how much is too much? I thought I bought the right yarn #5, I’m bought cheaper yarn to practice? I don’t easily give up but HELP.

    1. Hi Catherine,

      Okay, first things first, let’s check that you have the right supplies. Are you using the Oxford punch or the punch needle for embroidery floss? (It sounds like you are using bulky weight yarn, so I am assuming the Oxford punch.)
      Then, after that, what type of monk’s cloth are you using? If you bought the packaged monk’s cloth from Joann or Michaels, it’s probably not the right kind of monk’s cloth — which would explain some of your problems.

  14. I’m
    Using a snap frame like you suggested but can’t keep my fabric ( monks cloth ) tight. How do I fix this problem. It loosens with every stitch
    Thank you

    1. Hi Patti,
      What type of monk’s cloth are you using? Did you try pulling it tight after assembling the frame? I do find that I need to pull the edges tight again every so often — but like after 10 minutes of punching, not every stitch.

  15. Sandra Woods says:

    I am so interested in this, but I really want to know if you can sew “normal” stitches with this, i.e satin stitch and what stops the work unravelling if it gets caught on something and how I can prevent it.

    1. Yes, you certainly could sew normal stitches – sort of like a large-scale embroidery project.
      If you want to try the punch needle technique, I encourage you to give it a try. It’s the pressure and friction of the stitches against the fabric – and against each other – the hold the surround stitches in place.
      That said, if you do snap your work on something, there is the potential for it to pull some of the stitches out. (There’s less of a chance of that happening if you use 100% wool yarn.)

  16. I punched threads too close together and actually tore the foundation fabric. I removed the threads hoping to redo the area and discovered this. Is there any “fix” for this dilemma?

    1. If the fabric is torn, you most likely will need to start again with new fabric.

  17. Carole Murton says:

    Hi Sarah
    I am using weavers cloth but the fabric almost rips when I start punching !! I am using DMC thread . Any help would be appreciated .
    Carole

    1. Hi Carole, What needle tool are you using?

  18. Hi there I have done everything right I double checked and still it is coming out now I have holes everywhere

    1. Hmm, is there a chance you have too much tension on the yarn? You want the yarn to flow very smoothly from the ball through the tool with minimal resistance.

  19. Allison Edwards says:

    Somehow the thread got stuck in my needle. I have tried to pull it out, but it must be bunched up in it. How can I get it out??

  20. Allison Edwards says:

    Thread is stuck inside my punch needle. I can’t get it out. No way to pull it out.

    1. What type of needle are you using? Can you use a pipe cleaner or other small wire to push it out?

  21. Lida Tinkey says:

    When I push in fabric my needle wants to slide back in pen whst is wrong

    1. Sounds like the problem is the pen tool? Maybe you haven’t tightened it all the way?

    2. Jenniffer says:

      @Sarah, the needle goes into the lower tip of the piece that fits inside the punch tool. It wont slide out when it is that way.

  22. Pingback: 10 Tips for Punch Needle Embroidery Beginners - Sarah Maker
  23. Sindy Smith says:

    Good morning from a cool Autumn day in South Africa.
    I want to make a carpet with mt punch needle but how do I secure the wool to not come loose at the ends where I cut the strings of?
    Looking forward to your reply.
    Have a great day.
    Sindy Smith

  24. Jazmin Garcia says:

    My punch needle keeps going into the tube everytime I try to punch threw the cloth. I have tried to change it out with diffrent sizes but to no luck.

    1. Sarah Maker says:

      Hmm, I can’t say that’s ever happened to me. Are you saying that your tool is coming apart?

    2. Gwendolyn says:

      @Jazmin Garcia, mine too! Needle just goes back inside. Brand new, screw wont tighten enough to hold needle out

      1. What brand tool do you have?

  25. Pingback: Punch Needle Embroidery For Beginners - Giver's Log
  26. Pingback: The Best Punch Needle Kits - Giver's Log
  27. Pingback: The Best Punch Needle Supplies - Giver's Log

Similar Posts